Difference between revisions of "MKW Hack Pack/Track Wishlist"

From Custom Mario Kart
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 182: Line 182:
 
|}
 
|}
  
−
==== Rejected Tracks ====
+
==== Needs Fixes - May get into MKW Hack Pack ====
 
<spoiler>{| class="wikitable sortable"
 
<spoiler>{| class="wikitable sortable"
 
! width=132px| Track Name
 
! width=132px| Track Name
Line 188: Line 188:
 
! width=200px| Notes
 
! width=200px| Notes
 
! Track Review/Issues
 
! Track Review/Issues
−
|-
 
−
| [[3DS Wuhu Loop (MrDark35000vr)|3DS Wuhu Loop]]
 
−
| {{no|Rejected}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Cannons lead to fall boundaries, various kcl problems.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[79T Space Road]]
 
| [[79T Space Road]]
Line 213: Line 208:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Too many akward turns, doesn't exactly look fun to drive on.
 
| Too many akward turns, doesn't exactly look fun to drive on.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Autumn Treeway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| There's more texture glitches in this remake than in it's previous version.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Birdo Island]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Might accept Toxic Prime/slippery mac's version with fixes, to be discussed
 +
|-
 +
| [[Blue Green Road]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Track is too narrow, upscale will make it bigger. Road is boring, lack of detail.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Bob-omb Factory]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Feels quite empty and lacks the theme appropriate for the track. Could use some bomb cars and other bomb-oriented custom objects and a scale down.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Bowser Multiverse]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Very basic, boring, and one turn in particular can be tricky.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Candyland]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Textures seem underwhelming, and track feels cramped and not very engaging in my opinion. Also, better options for similar tracks.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Canyon Pass]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]] and [[KantoEpic]].
 +
| Textures could use some updating, shortcuts need to be nerfed.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Carrera Circuit (Skipper93653)|Carrera Circuit]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| This track has texture glitches and doesn't look very polished in light of the DS version.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Castle Island]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| It's very narrow, has bullet bill issues. Could use an overhaul.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Castle Moat]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| There's water on one small area of the track, and the textures could be better, not very engaging.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Christmas Raceway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Although it has some different objects that I'm not used to seeing, at the same time it looks bland.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Cold Circuit]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Initially accepted, but there are some things still needed to fix, downscale, change kcl, amongst other things
 +
|-
 +
| [[Colorful Paint]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Feels like a seizure waiting to happen honestly. Not going to take chances with this track unfortunately.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Containers Raceway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Sharp turns, there's a ledge that you can get stuck on, the layout is wonky.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Delfino Town]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| It's rather plain in it's current state, and the last turn is weird.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Desert of the Two Roads]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| One path is faster than the other. Looks rather generic
 +
|-
 +
| [[Deserted Mountain]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| It has potential, but the track is visually lackluster, and unintuitive in a few spots, with questionable kcl variants.
 +
|-
 +
| [[DK Falls]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Could use some work on becoming intuitive. Some blind turns, and sketchy texturing. Really seems promising though.
 +
|-
 +
| [[DK Jungle Tour II]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Needs clear fall boundaries and visual improvements
 +
|-
 +
| [[Dry Dry Temple]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Too many enemies, odd layout. Could use better textures and layout overall.
 +
|-
 +
| [[DS Tick-Tock Clock: Neo Edition]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Cannon is short and random, could use some [[KCL]] fixes and railings throughout the track.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Evening Creek]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| It looks really bland to play on, and has the potential for unwanted shortcuts.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Flameice Lagoon]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| v1.0
 +
| The track has collision issues, some areas where the snow isn't distinguishable from the main road and offroad. Could use some arrows and other improvements to be considered.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Forbidden Factory]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Although sight unseen, I'm rejecting this track due to what [[BillyNoodles]] told me about the track. It's an old track that just got released and not good.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Garden Path]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| There's other tracks that outshine this one, not really anything redeeming about this track.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Ghostly Mansion]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Texturing could be better, you can skip the mansion part by going offroad, making this track magikruiser friendly, and lack of out of bounds in the offroad sections.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Gold Leaf Skyway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| v1.1
 +
| Needs railings, redo the rainbow textures to something else. Other fixes to be considered.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Good Egg Raceway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| v1.0
 +
| Collision issues in the "tree" section, needs arrows and better collision in that section.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Ibuki Luigi's Mansion]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| The staircase section as a whole needs to be remade and the track needs to be upscaled before it's accepted.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Ice Creek]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Although initially accepted, it is now rejected because of being too bland, needs more objects and that first downhill slope needs some realignment.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Jungle Park]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| One of my gripes with the track are that the "rock walls" are sometimes in the way of this one shortcut. There's also various bugs and the fall boundary is odd.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Lakeside Lagoon‎]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| It feels really bland to me, could use some decoration, enemies, and other various objects.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Lecce's Classic Road]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Initially accepted, but because of questionable out of bounds and rather dull layout, it got rejected
 +
|-
 +
| [[Lecce's Desert]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Initially accepted, but it's quite dull and bland, plus there's other desert tracks that show more promise in the pack than this one
 +
|-
 +
| [[Lecce's Snow Road]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]]
 +
| Offroad snow is problematic, item routes bugged.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Lost Lake]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| The grass is out of bounds. Some unclear paths, wonky layout.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Mario Speedway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| No lap count bug, too much offroad, you can skip some parts of the track with speed mod.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Mountain Adventure]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| It's a lot like [[Mountain Town]] but bigger, it has stretched textures, which is minor but still a concern, [[KCL]] could be a problem. I would like to add a speed mod but that will probably add to the problems.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Mountain Road]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| The track has mismatched textures and boring straightaways.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Mushroom Byway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Although this track looks nice and clean, it looks boring, and long.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Mushroom Meadows]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Shortcut is very OP, feels like a very Magikruiser reliant track. Very lacking in objects, it's scaled a little too big for my liking despite the Magikruiser statement. Needs objects.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Negative Land]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| There's this one fall boundary that is like [[Yellow Loop]]'s fall boundary, it's not there and you have to start a turn all over again.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Nintendo Raceway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Has some awkwardly sharp turns and very generic. Also is named Nintendo, probably should be renamed to avoid copyright.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Nocturnal Coast]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Too long and too boring to be considered. If it was scaled down and had more objects maybe.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Oceanic Raceway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Feels a bit bland at this current state. There seem to be better options, [[Sandy Strait]], amongst other tracks.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Office Rush]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| The track is quite narrow in parts and texture glitches need to be fixed.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Penguin Canyon]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Although intially accepted, it's now rejected because of there being too many ice tracks and this remake doesn't make this track age well, it's rather bland and dull.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Powerpuff Funpark]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| It's promising, but the texturing could be so much better. Needs arrows and more objects
 +
|-
 +
| [[Purple Loop]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Initially accepted, but ultimately rejected, it's quite narrow, and the ending is harsh.
 +
|-
 +
| [[River Plains]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Could use some visual updates, animations, objects, ramp edits.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Riverside Circuit]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| The theme of the track is unclear, which is minor, and I prefer [[Water Village]] over this, along with [[Compact Highway]] because this track reminds me of that, since it was made by the same designer.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Rocky Hills]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Feels quite narrow, and based on these ports of Skipper's, it doesn't really offer anything different.
 +
|-
 +
| [[SBSPLCP Floor It 1]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| There's really nothing to this track, could use some custom Spongebob objects or something
 +
|-
 +
| [[Storage Unit]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Will be updated by the author
 +
| It's very bland even with changes made it won't make it in.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Sunset Circuit 2]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Although visually pleasing, it feels bland to me.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Sunset Circuit 3]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Another track that looks like some unintended grass cuts can be done on.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Tree Circuit]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Initially accepted, but the track lacks detail, and is scaled too large, speed mod wouldn't save it either.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Trek of Shapes]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Incredible glitchy, and too vibrant. Potential seizure hazard.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Troy Circuit 2013]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Wonky layout, too many mushrooms, weird offroad. Could use a scale down, less enemies.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Twilight Highway]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| Initially accepted, but after some consideration, it's quite bland, and has a bullet bug.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Volcano Canyon]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| The fencing on the top of the canyon isn't solid in one area, you can go right through it. Textures need updating too.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Withered Fortress]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Heavy lag due to textures, an update is pending right now.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Zelda TP Kakariko Village]]
 +
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 +
| Update by [[Huili]].
 +
| This track could use some arrows, updating textures are a must, block off paths that aren't needed. Basically a big overhaul.
 +
|-
 +
|}
 +
</spoiler>
 +
 +
==== Rejected Tracks - Won't get into MKW Hack Pack ====
 +
<spoiler>{| class="wikitable sortable"
 +
! width=132px| Track Name
 +
! Status
 +
! width=200px| Notes
 +
! Track Review/Issues
 +
|-
 +
| [[3DS Wuhu Loop (MrDark35000vr)|3DS Wuhu Loop]]
 +
| {{no|Rejected}}
 +
| &mdash;
 +
| Cannons lead to fall boundaries, various kcl problems.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Aquadrom Stage 2]]
 
| [[Aquadrom Stage 2]]
Line 233: Line 558:
 
| Remake by [[Retrostyle12]].
 
| Remake by [[Retrostyle12]].
 
| Not accepting anyone's version, they're all bland.
 
| Not accepting anyone's version, they're all bland.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Autumn Treeway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| There's more texture glitches in this remake than in it's previous version.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Azria Temple]]
 
| [[Azria Temple]]
Line 263: Line 583:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Interesting skybox, but boring track otherwise.
 
| Interesting skybox, but boring track otherwise.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Birdo Island]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Might accept Toxic Prime/slippery mac's version with fixes, to be discussed
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Black Loop]]
 
| [[Black Loop]]
Line 273: Line 588:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| The theme doesn't fit the name, and it doesn't look very appealing
 
| The theme doesn't fit the name, and it doesn't look very appealing
−
|-
 
−
| [[Blue Green Road]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Track is too narrow, upscale will make it bigger. Road is boring, lack of detail.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Blue Loop]]
 
| [[Blue Loop]]
Line 283: Line 593:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Rejecting all versions of this track, will wait for Atlas' version, if it ever comes out.
 
| Rejecting all versions of this track, will wait for Atlas' version, if it ever comes out.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Bob-omb Factory]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Feels quite empty and lacks the theme appropriate for the track. Could use some bomb cars and other bomb-oriented custom objects and a scale down.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Bowser Multiverse]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Very basic, boring, and one turn in particular can be tricky.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Bowser's Castle 1]]
 
| [[Bowser's Castle 1]]
Line 308: Line 608:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Got other similarly styled tracks that outshine this.
 
| Got other similarly styled tracks that outshine this.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Candyland]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Textures seem underwhelming, and track feels cramped and not very engaging in my opinion. Also, better options for similar tracks.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Cannon City II]]
 
| [[Cannon City II]]
Line 323: Line 618:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Even with the fixes, it stills feels quite bland.
 
| Even with the fixes, it stills feels quite bland.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Canyon Pass]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]] and [[KantoEpic]].
 
−
| Textures could use some updating, shortcuts need to be nerfed.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Carefree Crossing]]
 
| [[Carefree Crossing]]
Line 333: Line 623:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Trickable tree stumps are glitchy and track in general feel like a wannabee [[Crossingville]].
 
| Trickable tree stumps are glitchy and track in general feel like a wannabee [[Crossingville]].
−
|-
 
−
| [[Carrera Circuit (Skipper93653)|Carrera Circuit]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| This track has texture glitches and doesn't look very polished in light of the DS version.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Castle Island]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| It's very narrow, has bullet bill issues. Could use an overhaul.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Castle Moat]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| There's water on one small area of the track, and the textures could be better, not very engaging.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Cheese Road 1]]
 
| [[Cheese Road 1]]
Line 383: Line 658:
 
| v1.0
 
| v1.0
 
| If I wanted this, I'd take the retro variants, and I'm not interested in those either
 
| If I wanted this, I'd take the retro variants, and I'm not interested in those either
−
|-
 
−
| [[Christmas Raceway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Although it has some different objects that I'm not used to seeing, at the same time it looks bland.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Coin Soup Pot]]
 
| [[Coin Soup Pot]]
Line 393: Line 663:
 
| RC1
 
| RC1
 
| This track has no potential in it's current state. Feels a lot like [[Lava Fortress]] which is also rejected. Needs a visual overhaul potentially.
 
| This track has no potential in it's current state. Feels a lot like [[Lava Fortress]] which is also rejected. Needs a visual overhaul potentially.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Cold Circuit]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Initially accepted, but there are some things still needed to fix, downscale, change kcl, amongst other things
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Colorful Paint]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Feels like a seizure waiting to happen honestly. Not going to take chances with this track unfortunately.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Containers Raceway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Sharp turns, there's a ledge that you can get stuck on, the layout is wonky.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Crystal Valley]]
 
| [[Crystal Valley]]
Line 443: Line 698:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Rejecting this because it's a battle track, plain and simple.
 
| Rejecting this because it's a battle track, plain and simple.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Delfino Town]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| It's rather plain in it's current state, and the last turn is weird.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Desert City]]
 
| [[Desert City]]
Line 453: Line 703:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Despite it being the authors first track, feels rather underwhelming, might accept if improved on.
 
| Despite it being the authors first track, feels rather underwhelming, might accept if improved on.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Desert of the Two Roads]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| One path is faster than the other. Looks rather generic
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Desert Run 1]]
 
| [[Desert Run 1]]
Line 468: Line 713:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Lack of fall boundaries, and it's quite bland
 
| Lack of fall boundaries, and it's quite bland
−
|-
 
−
| [[Deserted Mountain]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| It has potential, but the track is visually lackluster, and unintuitive in a few spots, with questionable kcl variants.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[DK Falls]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Could use some work on becoming intuitive. Some blind turns, and sketchy texturing. Really seems promising though.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[DK Jungle Tour II]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Needs clear fall boundaries and visual improvements
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Donut Steppe 1]]
 
| [[Donut Steppe 1]]
Line 498: Line 728:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Not really anything bad to say, just not really feeling this track
 
| Not really anything bad to say, just not really feeling this track
−
|-
 
−
| [[Dry Dry Temple]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Too many enemies, odd layout. Could use better textures and layout overall.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Dry Island]]
 
| [[Dry Island]]
Line 513: Line 738:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| [[Warp Pipe Island]] makes this track obsolete
 
| [[Warp Pipe Island]] makes this track obsolete
−
|-
 
−
| [[DS Tick-Tock Clock: Neo Edition]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Cannon is short and random, could use some [[KCL]] fixes and railings throughout the track.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[DS Twilight House (Race)]]
 
| [[DS Twilight House (Race)]]
Line 548: Line 768:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Not accepting anyones version, they're bkland.
 
| Not accepting anyones version, they're bkland.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Evening Creek]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| It looks really bland to play on, and has the potential for unwanted shortcuts.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[F-Zero Mute City 1]]
 
| [[F-Zero Mute City 1]]
Line 563: Line 778:
 
| v1.1
 
| v1.1
 
| Just another BC3 rip off with some random elements. Would need an overhaul to be considered.
 
| Just another BC3 rip off with some random elements. Would need an overhaul to be considered.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Flameice Lagoon]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| v1.0
 
−
| The track has collision issues, some areas where the snow isn't distinguishable from the main road and offroad. Could use some arrows and other improvements to be considered.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Flooded Cavern]]
 
| [[Flooded Cavern]]
Line 573: Line 783:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| It's lacking detail, could use more objects and other stuff.
 
| It's lacking detail, could use more objects and other stuff.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Forbidden Factory]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Although sight unseen, I'm rejecting this track due to what [[BillyNoodles]] told me about the track. It's an old track that just got released and not good.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Frosty Mountains]]
 
| [[Frosty Mountains]]
Line 588: Line 793:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Needs respawn points and check points fixed. I was able to have the lap counted by being on the topmost route.
 
| Needs respawn points and check points fixed. I was able to have the lap counted by being on the topmost route.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Garden Path]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| There's other tracks that outshine this one, not really anything redeeming about this track.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[GCN Cookie Land (Race)]]
 
| [[GCN Cookie Land (Race)]]
Line 618: Line 818:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Questionable dark road, textures bright, same issues as the other 2.
 
| Questionable dark road, textures bright, same issues as the other 2.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Ghostly Mansion]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Texturing could be better, you can skip the mansion part by going offroad, making this track magikruiser friendly, and lack of out of bounds in the offroad sections.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Giant Highway]]
 
| [[Giant Highway]]
Line 638: Line 833:
 
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
| Weird [[KCL]] glitches, road edges could use some work. Better textures, more enemies would also be nice.
 
| Weird [[KCL]] glitches, road edges could use some work. Better textures, more enemies would also be nice.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Gold Leaf Skyway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| v1.1
 
−
| Needs railings, redo the rainbow textures to something else. Other fixes to be considered.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Good Egg Raceway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| v1.0
 
−
| Collision issues in the "tree" section, needs arrows and better collision in that section.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[GP Yoshi Park 1]]
 
| [[GP Yoshi Park 1]]
Line 663: Line 848:
 
| Remake by [[Retrostyle12]].
 
| Remake by [[Retrostyle12]].
 
| Rejecting all versions, as they're quite bland to me.
 
| Rejecting all versions, as they're quite bland to me.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Ibuki Luigi's Mansion]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| The staircase section as a whole needs to be remade and the track needs to be upscaled before it's accepted.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Ice Creek]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Although initially accepted, it is now rejected because of being too bland, needs more objects and that first downhill slope needs some realignment.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Italian Way]]
 
| [[Italian Way]]
Line 688: Line 863:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Better choices for similar tracks, plus this is a test track, probably not the best idea to add this in.
 
| Better choices for similar tracks, plus this is a test track, probably not the best idea to add this in.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Jungle Park]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| One of my gripes with the track are that the "rock walls" are sometimes in the way of this one shortcut. There's also various bugs and the fall boundary is odd.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Kamek's Castle]]
 
| [[Kamek's Castle]]
Line 728: Line 898:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| The whole theme of the track is silly, road texture is bland and mismatched, potential for overpowering shortcuts.
 
| The whole theme of the track is silly, road texture is bland and mismatched, potential for overpowering shortcuts.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Lakeside Lagoon‎]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| It feels really bland to me, could use some decoration, enemies, and other various objects.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Lakeside Skyway]]
 
| [[Lakeside Skyway]]
Line 753: Line 918:
 
| v1.0
 
| v1.0
 
| Between this or [[Cossland]] I'd pick Cossland, and that is also rejected and in need of fixes.
 
| Between this or [[Cossland]] I'd pick Cossland, and that is also rejected and in need of fixes.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Lecce's Classic Road]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Initially accepted, but because of questionable out of bounds and rather dull layout, it got rejected
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Lecce's Desert]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Initially accepted, but it's quite dull and bland, plus there's other desert tracks that show more promise in the pack than this one
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Lecce's Factory]]
 
| [[Lecce's Factory]]
Line 768: Line 923:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| It feels more like a ripoff of Toad's Factory than a custom track.
 
| It feels more like a ripoff of Toad's Factory than a custom track.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Lecce's Snow Road]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]]
 
−
| Offroad snow is problematic, item routes bugged.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Library of Shitopia]]
 
| [[Library of Shitopia]]
Line 783: Line 933:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Very random and unfitting track for Hack Pack.
 
| Very random and unfitting track for Hack Pack.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Lost Lake]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| The grass is out of bounds. Some unclear paths, wonky layout.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Love Circuit (Retrostyle12)|Love Circuit]]
 
| [[Love Circuit (Retrostyle12)|Love Circuit]]
Line 803: Line 948:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Even with the update, still don't want it, too many similar tracks that outshine this.
 
| Even with the update, still don't want it, too many similar tracks that outshine this.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Mario Speedway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| No lap count bug, too much offroad, you can skip some parts of the track with speed mod.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Mecha Donut Arena]]
 
| [[Mecha Donut Arena]]
Line 833: Line 973:
 
| v1.0
 
| v1.0
 
| Initially I thought I wanted this track, but now don't. The spiral on this track kills any potential and it's really bland otherwise.
 
| Initially I thought I wanted this track, but now don't. The spiral on this track kills any potential and it's really bland otherwise.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Mountain Adventure]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| It's a lot like [[Mountain Town]] but bigger, it has stretched textures, which is minor but still a concern, [[KCL]] could be a problem. I would like to add a speed mod but that will probably add to the problems.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Mountain Road]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| The track has mismatched textures and boring straightaways.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Mozzarella Mountain]]
 
| [[Mozzarella Mountain]]
Line 848: Line 978:
 
| v1.0
 
| v1.0
 
| Nothing wrong with the track, but seems underwhelming anyways. Maybe add decorations?
 
| Nothing wrong with the track, but seems underwhelming anyways. Maybe add decorations?
−
|-
 
−
| [[Mushroom Byway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Although this track looks nice and clean, it looks boring, and long.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Mushroom Meadows]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Shortcut is very OP, feels like a very Magikruiser reliant track. Very lacking in objects, it's scaled a little too big for my liking despite the Magikruiser statement. Needs objects.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[N64 Skyscraper (Race)]]
 
| [[N64 Skyscraper (Race)]]
Line 863: Line 983:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Rejecting this because it's a battle track, plain and simple.
 
| Rejecting this because it's a battle track, plain and simple.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Negative Land]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| There's this one fall boundary that is like [[Yellow Loop]]'s fall boundary, it's not there and you have to start a turn all over again.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Nexuz Road]]
 
| [[Nexuz Road]]
Line 873: Line 988:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| It looks really bland in it's current state, and it looks like unintended shortcuts maybe on the track.
 
| It looks really bland in it's current state, and it looks like unintended shortcuts maybe on the track.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Nintendo Raceway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Has some awkwardly sharp turns and very generic. Also is named Nintendo, probably should be renamed to avoid copyright.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Nocturnal Coast]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Too long and too boring to be considered. If it was scaled down and had more objects maybe.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Northpole Slide (Retrostyle12)|Northpole Slide]]
 
| [[Northpole Slide (Retrostyle12)|Northpole Slide]]
Line 888: Line 993:
 
| [[Retrostyle12]]'s remake
 
| [[Retrostyle12]]'s remake
 
| Too bland and narrow for my liking
 
| Too bland and narrow for my liking
−
|-
 
−
| [[Oceanic Raceway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Feels a bit bland at this current state. There seem to be better options, [[Sandy Strait]], amongst other tracks.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Office Rush]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| The track is quite narrow in parts and texture glitches need to be fixed.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Orange Loop]]
 
| [[Orange Loop]]
Line 908: Line 1,003:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Too simple and bland, and I already got enough similarly styled tracks going in.
 
| Too simple and bland, and I already got enough similarly styled tracks going in.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Penguin Canyon]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Although intially accepted, it's now rejected because of there being too many ice tracks and this remake doesn't make this track age well, it's rather bland and dull.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Perplexus]]
 
| [[Perplexus]]
Line 923: Line 1,013:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| The layout is very odd, ramps in the pipe section is random.
 
| The layout is very odd, ramps in the pipe section is random.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Powerpuff Funpark]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| It's promising, but the texturing could be so much better. Needs arrows and more objects
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Purple Loop]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Initially accepted, but ultimately rejected, it's quite narrow, and the ending is harsh.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Quadrate Circuit (Retrostyle12)|Quadrate Circuit]]
 
| [[Quadrate Circuit (Retrostyle12)|Quadrate Circuit]]
Line 948: Line 1,028:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Really boring straightaways and an awkward sharp turn.
 
| Really boring straightaways and an awkward sharp turn.
−
|-
 
−
| [[River Plains]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Could use some visual updates, animations, objects, ramp edits.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Riverside Circuit]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| The theme of the track is unclear, which is minor, and I prefer [[Water Village]] over this, along with [[Compact Highway]] because this track reminds me of that, since it was made by the same designer.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Rocky Hills]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Feels quite narrow, and based on these ports of Skipper's, it doesn't really offer anything different.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Rosalina's Purple Fortress]]
 
| [[Rosalina's Purple Fortress]]
Line 983: Line 1,048:
 
| Remade the model; update by [[Ptpix1]].
 
| Remade the model; update by [[Ptpix1]].
 
| The tracks layout and textures could be improved on, it's rather bland.
 
| The tracks layout and textures could be improved on, it's rather bland.
−
|-
 
−
| [[SBSPLCP Floor It 1]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| There's really nothing to this track, could use some custom Spongebob objects or something
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Scorched Sands (Sand Speedway II Texture)|Scorched Sands]]
 
| [[Scorched Sands (Sand Speedway II Texture)|Scorched Sands]]
Line 1,025: Line 1,085:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Sky Speedway]]
 
| [[Sky Speedway]]
−
| {{unknown|unreviewed}}
+
| {{no|Rejected}}
 
| RC2
 
| RC2
 
| In it's current state this track has no potential, it would have to be remade entirely to be considered.
 
| In it's current state this track has no potential, it would have to be remade entirely to be considered.
Line 1,103: Line 1,163:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Not much to this track, just a circle
 
| Not much to this track, just a circle
−
|-
 
−
| [[Storage Unit]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Will be updated by the author
 
−
| It's very bland even with changes made it won't make it in.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Sunset Bridge DX]]
 
| [[Sunset Bridge DX]]
Line 1,113: Line 1,168:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Some parts of the track are unintuitive. No railing to save you from falling.
 
| Some parts of the track are unintuitive. No railing to save you from falling.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Sunset Circuit 2]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Although visually pleasing, it feels bland to me.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Sunset Circuit 3]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Another track that looks like some unintended grass cuts can be done on.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Sunset Mountain]]
 
| [[Sunset Mountain]]
Line 1,150: Line 1,195:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Hole Cave]]
 
| [[The Hole Cave]]
−
| {{unknown|unreviewed}}
+
| {{no|Rejected}}
 
| RC2
 
| RC2
 
| In it's current state, this track has no potential, it would have to be remade in order for it to be considered.  
 
| In it's current state, this track has no potential, it would have to be remade in order for it to be considered.  
Line 1,168: Line 1,213:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Pretty bland and narrow, nothing much to see here
 
| Pretty bland and narrow, nothing much to see here
−
|-
 
−
| [[Tree Circuit]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Initially accepted, but the track lacks detail, and is scaled too large, speed mod wouldn't save it either.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Trek of Shapes]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Incredible glitchy, and too vibrant. Potential seizure hazard.
 
−
|-
 
−
| [[Troy Circuit 2013]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Wonky layout, too many mushrooms, weird offroad. Could use a scale down, less enemies.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Tsutomu's River]]
 
| [[Tsutomu's River]]
Line 1,193: Line 1,223:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Not really liking the track, seems like it could have some unintended shortcuts in it. There's other circuit tracks that seem to be better candidates too.
 
| Not really liking the track, seems like it could have some unintended shortcuts in it. There's other circuit tracks that seem to be better candidates too.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Twilight Highway]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| Initially accepted, but after some consideration, it's quite bland, and has a bullet bug.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[Unexcitebike Arena]]
 
| [[Unexcitebike Arena]]
Line 1,213: Line 1,238:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| It's slow, and it's just another SNES Vanilla  Lake 2.
 
| It's slow, and it's just another SNES Vanilla  Lake 2.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Volcano Canyon]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| The fencing on the top of the canyon isn't solid in one area, you can go right through it. Textures need updating too.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[N64 Wario Stadium (Skipper93653)|Wario Stadium]]
 
| [[N64 Wario Stadium (Skipper93653)|Wario Stadium]]
Line 1,248: Line 1,268:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Not very engaging, textures are boring, could be better
 
| Not very engaging, textures are boring, could be better
−
|-
 
−
| [[Withered Fortress]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| &mdash;
 
−
| Heavy lag due to textures, an update is pending right now.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[X Circuit]]
 
| [[X Circuit]]
Line 1,273: Line 1,288:
 
| &mdash;
 
| &mdash;
 
| Although the minimap is interesting, the track itself is nothing really special, quite bland.
 
| Although the minimap is interesting, the track itself is nothing really special, quite bland.
−
|-
 
−
| [[Zelda TP Kakariko Village]]
 
−
| {{no|Needs Fixes}}
 
−
| Update by [[Huili]].
 
−
| This track could use some arrows, updating textures are a must, block off paths that aren't needed. Basically a big overhaul.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|}
 
|}

Revision as of 18:15, 6 July 2020

For track wishlists for other distributions, see Track Wishlist.
Track Wishlist
This is the track wishlist for MKW Hack Pack.
General discussion goes on the talk page.
Notice!
Please keep alphabetical order when adding to this page!
Please do not make duplicate listings!

Legend

Accepted The track has been accepted without any issues.
Updated The track has been previously accepted, but has been updated since the latest review.
Rejected The track has been rejected since the latest review.
Updated The track has been previously rejected, but has been updated since the latest review.
Unreviewed The track has never been reviewed before.
Notice!
Add new tracks to the topmost table! If you don't, your course may stay unreviewed!
Notice!
Authors! If you have read the feedback for your rejected track(s), please remove its entry to make way for new ones!

MKW Hack Pack Wishlist

Track Name Status Track Slot Music Slot Laps Speed Notes Track Review/Issues
Camp Kartigan unreviewed Moonview Highway GCN Mario Circuit 3 1.0× RC1 —
Coin Heaven unreviewed Mushroom Gorge Mushroom Gorge 3 — v1.0 —
DS Tick Tock Clock unreviewed Toad's Factory N64 Skyscraper 3 1.0× Requires LE-Code —
Meadow Isle unreviewed GCN DK Mountain GCN DK Mountain 2 1.0× Beta update pending(?)
Notice!
Please do not add tracks or edit anything in this list below!
The tracks below have already been selected for review!

Tracks already reviewed for MKW Hack Pack

Accepted Tracks (vX)

Track Name Status Track Slot Music Slot Laps Speed Notes Track Review/Issues
Peak Garden updated DS Peach Gardens DS Peach Gardens 3 1.0× 4.0 —
Snowy Hills updated DK Summit DK Summit 3 1.0× 1.04 —
Universe Sandsoil updated Wario's Gold Mine Wario's Gold Mine 3 1.0× 1.6 —

Accepted Tracks (v?)

Track Name Status Track Slot Music Slot Laps Speed Notes Track Review/Issues
Astronomical Overdrive Needs Fixes Rainbow Road Rainbow Road 2 1.0× Version 1.0. Remove JHFR watermarking, add arrows to shortcuts, remove the "lens glare filter"
Aurora Field Updated Maple Treeway DS Peach Gardens 2 1.0× Version 1.1. —
Coin Runner Circuit Needs Fixes Luigi Circuit SNES Battle Course 4 3 1.0× v1.0 Could maybe benefit from some arrows in places and enemies.
Hells Dimension Accepted N64 Bowser's Castle N64 Bowser's Castle 2 1.0× v1.0 —
Nature Creek Pass Accepted GCN Mario Circuit GCN Mario Circuit 3 1.0× 1.0 Day/Regular —
Speedwagon Speedway Needs Fixes Mario Circuit GBA Battle Course 3 3 1.0× v1.0 Nothing major, just some visual textues changes to the road, and add some chain chomps, monty moles, etc.

Needs Fixes - May get into MKW Hack Pack

Show text


Rejected Tracks - Won't get into MKW Hack Pack

Show text

Retrieved from "https://wiki.tockdom.com/w/index.php?title=MKW_Hack_Pack/Track_Wishlist&oldid=205587"