Difference between revisions of "Talk:Autumn Leavesway II"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Autumn Leavesway II -- good reasons for a page split.) |
|||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
: I would prefer if it would be considered an update still. Like [[Forsaken Mansion]], [[Icecream Sweetland]], and [[Aquadrom Stage]], they also got big course makeovers, but didn't get a new name or split page. Mostly, the beginning section is the same, but the bridge section is now the treehouse section. But if it would be counted as a new track by most of the people, I already know a new name for it and I would also rename the old track, because of the grammar mistake. I don't know if that's possible or if the community would like that, because the name Autumn Leavesway has become iconic now. I want to gather more opinions from the other players whether I should do that or not. --[[User:Buschkling|Buschkling]] ([[User talk:Buschkling|talk]]) 06:23, 17 February 2018 (UTC) | : I would prefer if it would be considered an update still. Like [[Forsaken Mansion]], [[Icecream Sweetland]], and [[Aquadrom Stage]], they also got big course makeovers, but didn't get a new name or split page. Mostly, the beginning section is the same, but the bridge section is now the treehouse section. But if it would be counted as a new track by most of the people, I already know a new name for it and I would also rename the old track, because of the grammar mistake. I don't know if that's possible or if the community would like that, because the name Autumn Leavesway has become iconic now. I want to gather more opinions from the other players whether I should do that or not. --[[User:Buschkling|Buschkling]] ([[User talk:Buschkling|talk]]) 06:23, 17 February 2018 (UTC) | ||
| + | |||
| + | :: Maybe the other tracks are wrong! | ||
| + | :: Let's look from the position of a person, who doesn't know details about a track. He usually load the last version. And so he have never a chance to get a complete other track with the same name. [[Autumn Leavesway]] is of this kind, and for example [[Volcanic Skyway]] too. | ||
| + | :: You wrote as part of the history: ''Remake from scratch and complete new course layout''. It declares clearly, that v2 is a new track based on another one. The only common is the name. And this is misleading. And the Wiiki policy is and was always, that every track gets an own page. | ||
| + | :: -- [[User:Wiimm|Wiimm]] ([[User talk:Wiimm|talk]]) 10:19, 17 February 2018 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 10:19, 17 February 2018
Autumn Leavesway II
Comparing the minimaps, I find out, that v2 has complete other characteristics. So I think, it would be better, to call the new track »Autumn Leavesway II« and brand it as successor of »Autumn Leavesway« (without II).
-- Wiimm (talk) 20:53, 16 February 2018 (UTC)
- I would prefer if it would be considered an update still. Like Forsaken Mansion, Icecream Sweetland, and Aquadrom Stage, they also got big course makeovers, but didn't get a new name or split page. Mostly, the beginning section is the same, but the bridge section is now the treehouse section. But if it would be counted as a new track by most of the people, I already know a new name for it and I would also rename the old track, because of the grammar mistake. I don't know if that's possible or if the community would like that, because the name Autumn Leavesway has become iconic now. I want to gather more opinions from the other players whether I should do that or not. --Buschkling (talk) 06:23, 17 February 2018 (UTC)
- Maybe the other tracks are wrong!
- Let's look from the position of a person, who doesn't know details about a track. He usually load the last version. And so he have never a chance to get a complete other track with the same name. Autumn Leavesway is of this kind, and for example Volcanic Skyway too.
- You wrote as part of the history: Remake from scratch and complete new course layout. It declares clearly, that v2 is a new track based on another one. The only common is the name. And this is misleading. And the Wiiki policy is and was always, that every track gets an own page.
- -- Wiimm (talk) 10:19, 17 February 2018 (UTC)