Difference between revisions of "CTGP Revolution/Track Wishlist/New Tracks"

From Custom Mario Kart
Jump to: navigation, search
m
Line 140: Line 140:
 
|
 
|
 
|-
 
|-
 +
|-
 +
| [[Space Road]]
 +
| {{unknown|Unreviewed}}
 +
| Moonview Highway
 +
| Moonview Highway
 +
| –
 +
| —
 +
|
 +
|
 +
|
 
| [[Traffic Lights]]
 
| [[Traffic Lights]]
 
| {{unknown|Unreviewed}}
 
| {{unknown|Unreviewed}}

Revision as of 20:14, 6 May 2015

Template:CTGP Revolution/Track Wishlist

New Tracks

Overview

Newly released tracks since the last CTGP-R Update. No major glitches are known. Please indicate the desired slot and music in the "Notes" field. All tracks will be verified manually as the pack is assembled, and the status field will indicate progress. The decision to accept or reject a track lies solely on popular vote, and all tracks will be demonstrated on a live stream with at least 50 viewers to get opinions. Should a track be updated since the time of verification, please change the status field back to either "Unreviewed" or "Updated", and the track will be redownloaded and redemonstrated (including any previously rejected tracks). Any notes that track authors need to be aware of will be inserted in the "Issues/Track Review" field, and please feel free to delete erroneous information.

Legend

Accepted The track has been accepted without issue.
Needs Fixes The track has been accepted, but further action is recommended by the author.
Updated The track has been previously accepted, but has been updated since the latest stream.
Needs Fixes The track could be accepted, but further action is required by the author.
Updated The track could be accepted, and has been updated since the latest stream.
Rejected The track has been rejected since the latest stream.
Updated The track has been previously rejected, but has been updated since the latest stream.
Unreviewed The track has never been reviewed before.


Notice!
Add new tracks to the topmost table! If you don't, your course may stay unreviewed!
Notice!
Authors! If you have read the feedback for your rejected track(s), please remove its entry to make way for new ones!


Unreviewed Since Latest Stream

Track Name Status Track Slot Music Slot Laps Speed Modifier Notes Track Review/Issues
Cold Circuit Unreviewed Koopa Cape Koopa Cape
Dash Cannon Woods Unreviewed Maple Treeway Maple Treeway
DS DK Pass (Quajeek99 & Yoshidude4) Updated DK Summit DK Summit 3
GBA Riverside Park (ChaosShadow23) Updated N64 DK's Jungle Parkway N64 DK's Jungle Parkway 3 Slightly downscaled to fix KCL bug, checkpoints fixed and item routes fix over shortcut
GBA Sunset Wilds (ChaosShadow23) Updated DS Desert Hills DS Desert Hills 3 Minor texture fixes
Horror Mansion Unreviewed N64 Bowser's Castle SNES Ghost Valley 2 2
Lost Fortress Updated Bowser's Castle Bowser's Castle 3
Melting Magma Melee Updated Grumble Volcano 2 Added 2 lap modifer, changed road texture to brighter ice.
N64 Choco Mountain (Yoshidude4 & FunkyDude15) Unreviewed GCN DK Mountain GCN DK Mountain
SNES Choco Island 1 (NiAlBlack) Unreviewed SNES Mario Circuit 3 SNES Battle Course 4 This track might be a better solution for a good version of SNES Choco Island 1 instead of speed mod + bad off-road = bad gameplay. --Unsigned comment by Avenir (talk).
Space Road Unreviewed Moonview Highway Moonview Highway Traffic Lights Unreviewed SNES Ghost Valley 2 SNES Ghost Valley 2
Twin Peaks Updated Daisy Circuit 3 Scaled up 10%, added cameras
Windmill Village Updated DS Delfino Square DS Delfino Square 3 Minor texture and KMP fixes
Notice!
Please do not add tracks past this list!
The tracks below have already been selected for review!

Reviewed for v1.03.1000 (2015-05-03 - 2015-05-05)

Track Name Status Track Slot Music Slot Laps Speed Modifier Notes Track Review/Issues
3DS Toad Circuit (SKmarioman) Accepted Luigi Circuit N64 Mario Raceway
Abandoned Pier Rejected SNES Ghost Valley 2 SNES Ghost Valley 2 Not a lot has changed since previous review.
Alpine Skyway Accepted DK Summit DK Summit
Anime Circuit Rejected SNES Mario Circuit 3 SNES Mario Circuit 3 Generally awkward track to drive.
Autumn Forest Accepted Maple Treeway Maple Treeway 4 But it won't be 4 laps by popular demand. 3 or 5?
Autumn Leavesway Accepted Maple Treeway Maple Treeway 3
Autumn Raceway Rejected Maple Treeway Maple Treeway Awkward to drive, and we've got enough Autumn tracks.
Bayside Boulevard Accepted Koopa Cape GCN Peach Beach 3 The blind turns are a little problematic, however.
Birthday Party Rejected Luigi Circuit Luigi Circuit 3 Not a lot to see, and I'm not sure non-solid walls with block colours are the finest invention.
Blackrose Castle Accepted Mushroom Gorge N64 Bowser's Castle 3
Candy Mountains Accepted Maple Treeway Though this track is exceptionally bumpy.
CBFD Overworld Rejected Mushroom Gorge Maple Treeway A lot to see, but KCL errors and texturing make the track hard to play.
Celestial Ruins Needs Fixes Mushroom Gorge N64 Bowser's Castle 3 The fog was annoying people, and other minor gripes.
The Chamber Rejected Rainbow Road Rainbow Road 1 Accepting this track would probably stop MKW from being rated "E".
Color Wonderland Needs Fixes Rainbow Road Rainbow Road 3 This track is very hard to see because of bright block colours. Maybe if it were darkened and the textures had more detail...?
Compact Highway Rejected DS Desert Hills DS Desert Hills 5 Added more objects You might want to fix the walls. Items go right through them!
Cookie Village Accepted DS Yoshi Falls DS Yoshi Falls 3
Crossingville Accepted Koopa Cape Moo Moo Meadows 3 ≤ 1.2×
Cyberstate Needs Fixes GBA Bowser Castle 3 GBA Bowser Castle 3 3 A neat concept, but there are few texture issues, and signposting for blind turns might also be nice.
Daisy Gardens Accepted DS Peach Gardens DS Peach Gardens 2 ≤ 1.1×
Desert Castle Raceway Accepted DS Desert Hills 1 I would recommend simplifying the interior of the castle, however.
Desert Fort Needs Fixes Dry Dry Ruins Dry Dry Ruins 3 There is an ultra glitch. This track plays things very safe. Consider a speed modifier or adding more objects?
Desert Raceway Needs Fixes Dry Dry Ruins Dry Dry Ruins 3 Not a whole lot is going on in this track. Would benefit from more slopes, perhaps!
Desert Tower Rejected Dry Dry Ruins Dry Dry Ruins 3 Layout could use work.
Disco Fever Accepted Rainbow Road GCN Waluigi Stadium Just in case of copyright (on the dance-screen textures of the SNSD edition), then use the Super Mario edition. Will use Super Mario edition.
Divine Temple Rejected Mushroom Gorge Rainbow Road 2 Position tracker issues and an impossible mandatory spiral section.
Dry Dry Temple Needs Fixes DS Desert Hills Dry Dry Ruins 3 The layout is very tricky to work with in places.
DS DK Pass (Quajeek99 & Yoshidude4) Needs Fixes DK Summit DK Summit 3 The wall of fall death boundary protecting the OOB areas at the large jump is annoying and triggers too often.
Fire Palace Accepted Grumble Volcano Bowser's Castle 3
Gate of Dreams Rejected Rainbow Road Rainbow Road 3 Track updated and item routes fixed The layout is definitely a problem, most of the jumps are awkward and blind.
GBA Bowser Castle 2 (FunkyDude15 & Yoshidude4) Rejected GBA Bowser Castle 3 GBA Bowser Castle 3 We already have a GBA Bowser Castle 2.
GBA Bowser Castle 4 (Yoshidude4 & FunkyDude15) Rejected GBA Bowser Castle 3 GBA Bowser Castle 3 We already have a GBA Bowser Castle 4.
GBA Cheese Land (ChaosShadow23) Accepted Moo Moo Meadows Moo Moo Meadows 3
GBA Lakeside Park (ChaosShadow23) Accepted N64 DK's Jungle Parkway N64 DK's Jungle Parkway 3
GBA Peach Circuit (NiAlBlack) Rejected N64 Mario Raceway N64 Mario Raceway 3 We already have a GBA Peach Circuit.
GBA Riverside Park (ChaosShadow23) Accepted N64 DK's Jungle Parkway N64 DK's Jungle Parkway 3
GBA Sunset Wilds (ChaosShadow23) Accepted DS Desert Hills DS Desert Hills 3
Ghostly Mansion Rejected SNES Ghost Valley 2 SNES Ghost Valley 2 3 Certain textures make the track hard to see. Layout is strange in places.
Glacial Peak Rejected DK Summit A cool idea, but there's sadly not much to see. Could be great if worked on more.
Hell Pyramid Accepted Grumble Volcano Grumble Volcano 3
Hillside Circuit Needs Fixes Daisy Circuit N64 Mario Raceway 3 We have to decide what to do with the overpowered shortcut.
Infernal Pipeyard Accepted Grumble Volcano Grumble Volcano 3
Jungle Cliff Accepted
Lost Fortress Needs Fixes Bowser's Castle Bowser's Castle 3 The CPUs hate this track with a passion!
Luigi's Ghost Castle Rejected SNES Ghost Valley 2 SNES Ghost Valley 2 2 Some of the turns are too illogical, and the jumps too large.
Melting Magma Melee Needs Fixes Grumble Volcano 2 We may update the ice texture so it isn't blinding cyan in colour. Checkpoints also need rearranging for 2 lap modifier. Signposting the shortcut would be smart.
Nebula Lava Factory Needs Fixes Bowser's Castle Bowser's Castle 3 Blind turns after hilltops are not a good thing, as Mushroom Peaks proves. Some track routes are not clear.
The Nether Rejected Grumble Volcano Grumble Volcano 3 The mushroom part is pretty hard. The texturing is too hard to look at!
Nivurbia Needs Fixes DK Summit DK Summit 3 Can be awkward to drive in places.
Nocturne Circuit Rejected N64 Mario Raceway or
Mario Circuit
Moonview Highway 1.2× Too bland. Speed modifiers will be too fast for some hairpin turns.
Nostalgic Bowser's Castle Accepted N64 Bowser's Castle N64 Bowser's Castle 2
ONI Training Place Rejected Dry Dry Ruins So much potential! Just needs a bit more work to live up to it.
Pipeline Skyway Rejected Mushroom Gorge Mushroom Gorge 3 Item and enemy routes aren't perfect. The left finish line post isn't solid on one side. The potential is there, it just needs to be easier to drive.
Powerpuff Funpark Rejected DS Yoshi Falls DS Yoshi Falls 3 This track has been accepted before, but the textures were copyrighted. Copyrighted textures are now removed. The layout and texturing are both issues.
Purple Route Rejected Rainbow Road Rainbow Road Plagiarism, and nothing's changed. Don't resubmit for review without actually looking at the notes and attempting to fix the problem.
Rainbow Jungle Rejected Rainbow Road Rainbow Road 3 Still no good. A jungle is not a small pile of trees at a start line, and the rest of the track is nothing special.
River of Dreams Accepted Koopa Cape Rainbow Road 1 Must use the SZS inside the "just for CTGP" folder. Got it!
Rosalina's Starlight Coaster Accepted DK Summit Rainbow Road 2 ≤ 1.2×
Skyline Avenue Accepted DS Desert Hills Moonview Highway 3
SM64 Cool, Cool Mountain Slide Rejected If you need blue boosts, show them! It doesn't have to be so faithful to the original that you can't add stuff. People didn't feel like this would be a good choice.
SMS Sirena Beach Rejected This is not what we'd call "drivable".
SNES Bowser Castle 3 (Rukasudo90 & WhiteMEX) Rejected GBA Bowser Castle 3 GBA Bowser Castle 3 We already have two SNES Bowser Castle 3s.
SNES Donut Plains 3 (James) Rejected SNES Mario Circuit 3 Too outdated by comparison to other offer.
SNES Donut Plains 3 (Yoshidude4) Needs Fixes SNES Mario Circuit 3 SNES Mario Circuit 3 While accurate and the bloopers are fun, it's just not very rewarding or interesting to drive.
Space City Rejected Not all that interesting as it currently stands.
Space Island Rejected Rainbow Road Rainbow Road Too awkward to drive!
Spike Desert Accepted Dry Dry Ruins Dry Dry Ruins 3
SSBB Mario Circuit (Mewtwo2000) Rejected N64 Mario Raceway N64 Mario Raceway This track has not been updated since the last time! Don't resubmit without making changes!
Toad Town Rejected Luigi Circuit or
Mario Circuit or
N64 Mario Raceway
Luigi Circuit or
Mario Circuit or
N64 Mario Raceway
This track has not been updated since the last time! Don't resubmit without making changes!
Tomb of Anubis Rejected Dry Dry Ruins Dry Dry Ruins Far far far too awkward to drive at the moment.
Twin Peaks Accepted Daisy Circuit 3 Though changes to the river section are recommended. Getting to it and through it is awkward on multiple vehicles.
Underwater Slide Rejected Koopa Cape Koopa Cape Could use a visual overhaul.
Volcano Canyon Accepted Luigi Circuit
Wheel Rock Rejected DS Desert Hills DS Desert Hills Unfortunately not very fun to drive.
Windmill Village Accepted DS Delfino Square DS Delfino Square
Winter Paradise Accepted N64 Sherbet Land N64 Sherbet Land 3
Wolf Castlegrounds Accepted SNES Mario Circuit 3 N64 Bowser's Castle 3
Wong Speed Rejected N64 DK's Jungle Parkway N64 Mario Raceway 3 Boost tracks probably aren't necessary anymore thanks to speed modifiers.
Zelda WW Outset Island Rejected GCN Peach Beach GCN Peach Beach Layout is problematic. Out of bounds needs to be more clearly marked.

Reviewed for v1.03.0000 (2013-09-28)

Track Name Status Notes Track Review/Issues
8-Bit Road Needs Fixes N64 Mario Raceway track slot/music slot requested
Alpha Boost Road Needs Fixes Rainbow Road Slot & Music
Gate of Dreams Needs Fixes Rainbow Road music and track slot. SZS File sent to Mr Bean privately.
Ghostly Mansion Needs Fixes SNES Ghost Valley 2 music requested
Halloween Land Needs Fixes Please use Maple Treeway slot v1 bugs fixed
Paradoxic Worldway Needs Fixes 1 Lap requested. Rainbow Road Slot & Music